Islamorada Fish Company - Islamorada, Florida

Amy K.

We had a great meal at Islamorada Fish Company. You can’t beat Sunset, live music, fire show as you are sitting by the water side to dine in.
Fish and chip was so good! They made with Cobia which is rare to find.
I liked Cobb salad with grilled shrimps.
As a local resident of Islamorada, we’ve been coming here for over 15 years. During pandemic we came a few times and were so disappointed so we stopped coming for a while. As came back and tried food and they have changed the menu and food quality was good!
Definitely recommend to stop by at Islamorada Fish Company for early dinner and you will see the best sunset in Islamorada.

Daniel O.

Great place. The perfect connecting moment with nature. It was surrounded by an amazing ambiance where delicious food and incredible customer service make your experience a very special one. It is definitely a must do when going down to the keys.

Yolanda G.

Great place to stop. We sat out by outside under covered tiki by the boats and tarpon deeding for eats and drinks. We had the fish and chips for lunch. Our fish tasted great taste and big pieces! Our waitress, Yloria, was so friendly that it started our vacation on a great foot!! And you have to try the key lime pie/dessert! Not too sweet or tart, but wonderfully creamy and delicious! Some great views! We shopped at the store next door, but don't forget to bring your Bass Pro shop gift cards!!
Overall, great stop!!!

Brenda H.

This location has great potential but the food needs work. The coleslaw was extremely salty, the fish was not cooked well, and the fries were not good. However, the coconut shrimp were pretty good. The views are gorgeous and the tarpon are entertaining to watch.

Cathy S.

Service was great. We had a wonderful waitress who was attentive, friendly, and engaging.

The food we ordered was very good. Husband got the whole yellow fin snapper with a huge quantity of green beans and mashed potatoes. Definitely something he'd order again. I got the grilled Parmesan chicken that came with A large portion of asparagus covered in the same sauce that the chicken was and a medium size of mashed potatoes. Not sure why his was double the size of mine but it was still a good portion. The chicken was tasty. It had a nice cream sauce on it though. I wouldn't say that the amount of chicken was huge but it was a fair size. And the key lime pie was good and totally shareable.

I don't know if this place offers portable heaters in their outdoor dining, but there were none in the ceiling area and it was a Cool. Slightly breezy evening. In that case, I suggest sitting more in the center of the outside section. We were seated right by the water where the cool Factor was more noticeable.

The views are very nice. The only thing I would ding it on and I'm sure this has nothing to do with them is a fishing vessel that is moored up to the pier which completely blocked our view of the sunset. Not that we couldn't walk around and still get pictures of the sunset, but the ugly fishing boat was just a slight detractor. Otherwise this was one of our more favorite meals in the area. We would definitely go back.

Mr3dPHD

You might think that little building right off the road is Islamorada Fish Company, but you would be wrong. That's the fish market. The restaurant itself is huge, spanning several docks along the water in the back!

This is a great place with a killer atmosphere and excellent food. The staff is extremely friendly and experienced as well. In the middle of the restaurant is a huge area of water surrounded by dock which is jam packed with tarpon. You can get a bag of bait for about $7 and feed the fish, which my daughter absolutely loved, while waiting for your food.

The wahoo dip is highly recommended! So good. Also recommended is the grouper Reuben, and believe it or not, the kids crispy fish tenders. Their fries are also fantastic!

Ben S.

This one gets 5 stars based on fish tacos and superb service at the bar. Great views of one of the best sport fishing fleets you’ll see in the keys and gulf side. Great shopping at World wide sports with everything a sun and fishing enthusiasts would want. Come sit and enjoy.

Craig R.

The food was delicious, we got the coconut crusted shrimp tacos, Mahi tacos, and the calamari was so good we came back the next day, and I had 2 orders of them and the wife had the fish and chips. Leslie was our server and she was awesome!!